Tuesday, November 17, 2026Vol. III, No. 321 · Free to all readers
65Nation
65Nation
Subscribe
Lifestyle

How to Spot Quality Furniture at a Thrift Store

brown wooden chairs, table, and cabinet

There has never been a better time to go thrift shopping for furniture. As more Baby Boomers downsize their homes, a wave of well-made, older pieces is landing in secondhand shops across the country. Some people are calling this the Golden Age of Thrifting and honestly, that feels about right.

But not every old piece is worth your money. The trick is knowing how to tell real quality from something that just looks good at first glance.

Folks at Reader’s Digest talked with Danielle Sandusky, co-owner of Modern Bungalow, an award-winning furniture boutique known for American-made, Amish-built, solid-wood pieces. She shared exactly what to look for and what to walk away from.

 

Is older furniture really built better?

Often, yes. Before large-scale industrial production took over, many furniture makers relied on skilled craftspeople and hands-on methods. The result was pieces built to last decades.

That changed when engineered wood, particleboard, and laminates became standard. As Sandusky puts it, mass-produced furniture is carefully designed to look good in photos and from just one angle. Pull out the drawers or open the doors, and the difference becomes clear.

That said, age alone does not guarantee quality. Some older furniture was never particularly well made to begin with. The key is learning to recognize what good construction actually looks like.

Five things to check before you buy

1. Pick it up and push on it

Solid hardwood has real heft to it. If a piece feels surprisingly light, that can be a sign of thinner materials or hollow components. Sandusky recommends pushing gently on a corner to test stability. A good dresser, table, or cabinet should not wobble when you touch it.

For upholstered pieces, press down on the arms and back. If the frame bows, feels squishy, or seems unstable, the structural support may not be there. Sagging cushions or wooden corners poking through the fabric are also warning signs.

2. Look closely at the wood

 

Hardwoods like maple, cherry, oak, and walnut are denser and heavier than softer alternatives. Flip the piece over and check the underside, back, and edges. Does the grain look consistent all the way through, or does it appear to be a thin decorative layer over something cheaper?

Sandusky suggests checking the underside of wooden tables in particular. A rough, unfinished, or splintery surface may be a sign the maker did not put much care into the construction. You can also press a fingernail gently against an inconspicuous spot to get a feel for the wood’s density.

3. Check the drawer corners for dovetail joints

Dovetail joints are the interlocking, wedge-shaped connections you find at the corners of a well-built drawer. They hold the pieces together without relying entirely on nails or screws, and they are a classic sign of quality construction. Look for them in dressers, desks, and cabinets.

Here is Sandusky’s tip: do not stop at the front corners. Some manufacturers use dovetail joints only at the front to create the appearance of quality. Pull the drawer all the way out and inspect the back corners too. Ideally, the drawer box itself should be solid wood, not plywood.

4. Hunt for a maker’s mark

A label, stamp, or signature can tell you a great deal about when a piece was made and who made it. Check the back of the furniture, inside drawers, and the bottom of cabinets. A maker’s mark can help you research the manufacturer and determine whether the piece belongs to a recognizable design collection.

Keep in mind that a missing mark does not mean a piece is not valuable. Many older furnishings were never labeled, and markings can disappear over time. Think of a maker’s mark as a helpful starting point, not a requirement.

5. Inspect every inch of the condition

Even a beautifully built piece can become a money pit if it needs major repairs. Look carefully at areas that are not immediately visible. Watch for loose joints, water damage, warped wood, significant cracks, and evidence of previous repairs. Check that drawers slide smoothly and that doors open and close without trouble.

Not every flaw is a dealbreaker. Sandusky says surface scratches, worn hardware, sticky drawers, and slightly crooked doors are often easy to fix. A cleaning, a touch-up kit, or replacement hardware may be all a piece needs.

What to avoid: do not underestimate the cost of refinishing an entire piece. Stripping old finishes, repairing damaged wood, and applying a new finish can require serious time, skill, and money. Know the difference between a cosmetic issue and a structural one before you commit.

How to recognize furniture from different eras

Knowing what era a piece comes from can help you understand what to look for and what it might be worth. Here is a quick guide to the major styles you are likely to encounter.

  • Victorian (1837–1900s): Dark woods, intricate carvings, curved lines, button-tufted upholstery, marble tops, and decorative hardware. Ornate and substantial.
  • Arts and Crafts (1880–1920s): A reaction against industrial excess. Sturdy oak construction, straight lines, exposed joinery, and understated hardware. Mission-style chairs, bookcases, and dining tables are common examples.
  • Art Nouveau (1890–1910s): Flowing, organic lines inspired by nature. Look for curved silhouettes, floral motifs, decorative inlays, and sometimes stained glass.
  • Art Deco (1920–1930s): Glamorous and streamlined. Geometric patterns, symmetrical shapes, mirrored surfaces, high-gloss finishes, and exotic veneers like walnut and Macassar ebony. Waterfall dressers are a classic example.
  • Mid-century Modern (1945–1970s): Clean lines, tapered legs, low profiles, warm-toned woods like teak and walnut. Credenzas, lounge chairs, and dining sets are especially recognizable finds.

One important point from Sandusky: a piece does not have to belong to a famous era to be worth buying. As she puts it, most of us are not looking to collect; we are looking to furnish our lives. Do not pass up a well-made, beautiful piece just because you cannot pin down its exact style.

Tools that can help you on the spot

You do not need to be an antiques expert to shop smart. A few simple tools can help.

  • Google Lens: Snap a photo of an unfamiliar piece and use Google Lens to search for visually similar items. It can help you identify a style, find a possible manufacturer, or spot useful search terms. You can also photograph a maker’s label to see if it matches a known brand. Keep in mind that similar-looking pieces are not always authentic originals.
  • WorthPoint: This site offers a database of historical auction and marketplace sales, along with tools for identifying makers’ marks. Its more extensive features require a subscription, but it can be useful if you shop secondhand regularly.
  • Completed sales on eBay, LiveAuctioneers, or Chairish: Look at what comparable pieces actually sold for, not just what sellers are asking. An asking price is not the same as a selling price.
  • An antiques or furniture specialist: If a piece has an unusual maker’s mark or a potentially important design history, consider asking an experienced dealer, restorer, or appraiser. Bring clear photos of the front, back, underside, drawers, hardware, and any markings. For a substantial purchase, an in-person inspection is even better.

How to know if the price is right

The lowest price tag is not always the best deal. Factor in the quality of the construction, the overall condition, the work it needs, and what comparable pieces are actually selling for. A sturdy table with a few surface scratches can be an excellent purchase. A piece with broken structural joints and a finish that needs complete stripping could cost you far more than the sticker price suggests.

Also ask yourself the practical questions. Will it fit in your home? Does it serve a purpose you actually need? Will you enjoy it for years to come? A well-made piece you will truly use is a better investment than an expensive collectible that does not suit your life.

Sandusky sums it up simply: If it’s well made and makes your heart sing, grab it.

One last thought before you go

Sandusky’s bigger advice is to think of thrifting as furnishing your life, not building an investment portfolio. Don’t buy to flip, she says. Buy to make your home feel collected and cozy, full of the work of craftspeople grateful to you for giving their labor a second life.

That is a pretty good reason to get out there this weekend and see what is waiting for you.

Share this article

 

Free daily subscription

Have tomorrow’s edition on your doorstep

Join 100,000 subscribers who are 60+ to receive our free daily newsletter with interesting news briefs and fun facts. No charge, no politics, cancel any time.