Friday, November 20, 2026Vol. III, No. 324 · Free to all readers
65Nation
65Nation
Subscribe
Just for Grandparents

Why Saying ‘You’re So Smart’ Can Backfire With Kids

boy writing

The grandkids bring home a perfect spelling test, or figure out a tricky puzzle on the first try. And out it comes, warm and automatic: You are so smart!

It feels like exactly the right thing to say. For generations, it has been the go-to expression of pride. But, according to Parade, child psychologists say that the four-word compliment may be doing more harm than good.

What Happens Inside a Child Who Is Labeled ‘Smart’

Dr. Brittney Pearson, PhD, a licensed psychologist with Thriveworks, explains that telling children they are smart inadvertently reinforces a fixed mindset: the belief that intelligence is something you either have or you do not.

Once a child takes on that label as part of their identity, they feel pressure to protect it. Dr. Amy Kincaid Todey, PhD, a child psychologist with Todey Psychology, says that mistakes start to feel threatening. The child’s internal question becomes: What if this proves I’m not actually smart?

Rather than risk that conclusion, Dr. Todey explains, many children begin avoiding challenges altogether. They choose easier tasks where success is guaranteed.

Dr. Cheung Tsang, PsyD, a neuropsychologist with Hackensack University Medical Center, puts it plainly: the way a parent (or grandparent) speaks to a child eventually becomes how that child talks to themselves.

What starts as an encouraging word can quietly grow into perfectionism, avoidance, and a fear of taking healthy risks.

What to Say Instead

The good news? A small shift in how you praise makes a big difference. Child psychologists say the key is to focus on effort, not ability.

Dr. Brett A. Biller, PsyD, Mental Health Director at the Audrey Hepburn Children’s House at Hackensack University Medical Center, says praising effort is far more productive than praising outcome. As he puts it, we have little control over outcome, but effort is something we can actually encourage.

Here are four approaches the psychologists recommend:

  • Praise the work, not the talent. Instead of calling them a natural genius, try something like: I noticed how hard you worked on that and how you tried three different approaches before you figured it out. Dr. Todey says this shows children you care about their dedication, not just the final score.
  • Treat mistakes as part of learning. A simple phrase like It’s okay to make mistakes; that’s how we learn removes the sting of imperfection and keeps curiosity alive.
  • Ask questions instead of jumping in. When a grandchild hits a wall, Dr. Tsang suggests asking: That didn’t go how you expected. What do you think you could try next? This moves the focus from failure to problem-solving.
  • Swap out old sayings. Replace practice makes perfect with practice makes progress. It reminds kids that growth is gradual, not all-or-nothing.

None of this means holding back your pride. It just means pointing it in a new direction toward the grit and curiosity that will serve your grandchildren long after the test is graded and the puzzle is put away.

That kind of encouragement? That is something only you can give.

Share this article

 

Free daily subscription

Have tomorrow’s edition on your doorstep

Join 100,000 subscribers who are 60+ to receive our free daily newsletter with interesting news briefs and fun facts. No charge, no politics, cancel any time.